The steeple from Ascension Lutheran Church now belongs to the Town of Paradise Valley. In late October 2026, the Arizona Digital Free Press reported that the spire had been taken down and placed in the Town's care, and that Town Hall had been approved as its permanent site, with installation still being planned. The church building is gone. The Paradise Valley Independent reported that Cole Mecray's CHM Holdings bought the property for $11 million and that it would be redeveloped as four single-family lots. Modern Luxury profiled the project as Mockingbird Estates, built by Hunt Developers, the firm Mecray founded. That profile also says Hunt paid to remove the steeple so it could be donated to the community. In July 2026 the Phoenix Business Journal reported that the first of the four homes would be priced at $30 million.
A developer buys a site, clears it and sells finished estates. That is how much of the upper end of the Paradise Valley market gets supplied today. Above $10 million, a buyer is often negotiating with a developer who has a design team, construction financing and a schedule. The buyer's room on price depends on where the house sits in that schedule, much more than on any town-wide median.
How Much of the Top Tier Comes From Builders
The Phoenix Business Journal counted 40 Paradise Valley closings above $10 million in 2026 through mid-October. The same outlet's coverage over the year keeps returning to new construction:
- In February it reported a $16.5 million cash sale of a recently built estate, which it called the highest-priced sale in the Valley so far that year.
- In late March it reported a newly built estate that sold for $16 million in two days, at more than $1,900 per square foot, and said its developers had five more mansions in the works.
- In June it reported a completed Yonker spec home priced at $17.5 million.
- On November 6 it reported a newly built Paradise Valley mansion listed at $55 million. It was one of five properties over $10 million that went on the market the same day.
The price per square foot shows what a new build commands here. The March sale closed at more than $1,900 a foot. The town-wide median sold price per square foot in September 2026 was $775, according to Scottsdale REALTORS' Paradise Valley market report, and that figure barely changed from $776 in April 2026. A finished spec estate can trade at roughly two and a half times the town's median price per foot. At that premium, the timing of the purchase matters more than the median does.
Before the First Wall, the Price Is the Builder's Plan
Several of the most-reported 2026 figures were set before a house existed. In March, the Phoenix Business Journal reported that four homesites near the Ritz-Carlton development, being developed by a Texas firm, had been approved and were expected to list for $30 million apiece. In July, the same outlet reported that Vault Leverage Capital had closed a $14.2 million loan on a planned 14,000-square-foot spec home with full Camelback Mountain views, which was set to list at $30 million once built. The first Mockingbird Estates home was given the same $30 million figure.
These numbers are the builders' targets, set from renderings before any buyer has made an offer. The Vault loan also shows how these projects are funded, with an eight-figure construction loan behind a single spec estate. A buyer who follows a project from the start knows the builder's original target, and that figure is the reference point for every price that comes after it.
As Construction Wraps, the Best-Placed Homes Move Quickly
The window around completion is where Paradise Valley specs have sold fastest. In February 2025 the Phoenix Business Journal reported a Mummy Mountain spec estate that sold for $15.3 million after it went under contract while construction was wrapping up. The March 2026 sale with Camelback Mountain views took two days.
In both cases the builder had a well-placed new house, a short marketing period and proof that buyers wanted it. That leaves the buyer little room on price. A buyer who wants a home like these is mostly competing on readiness: financing lined up, decisions made, and the ability to act within days.
Once a Finished Spec Sits, the Calendar Favors the Buyer
Some finished specs sell slowly, and the clearest recent example comes from December 2025. The Phoenix Business Journal reported that a newly built 10,095-square-foot Paradise Valley spec estate, first listed at nearly $19 million, sold for $14.8 million after a $4.2 million price cut. The outlet wrote that many luxury listings at the time were selling for millions of dollars less than their asking prices. At the sale price, that works out to about $1,466 a square foot. That is well below the $1,900-plus a foot reported three months later for the two-day sale, though still almost twice the town-wide median.
That spread is the most useful number in this post for a buyer. Two newly built Paradise Valley estates, sold three months apart, closed more than $400 a square foot apart. One sold in two days, and the other sold only after a cut of more than a fifth of its original asking price. A finished spec that has been listed for a while is a different negotiation from one that is just reaching completion, even when both come from the same tier of the same town.
The Record Sale Was a Six-Year-Old House
The most expensive home sale in Arizona history was not a new spec. AZ Big Media reported that the $40.2 million all-cash sale in July 2026 was a nearly 21,000-square-foot estate at 5531 E. Mockingbird Lane, built in 2020.
This matters to anyone shopping new construction, because many top-tier resales in Paradise Valley are themselves builder output from only a few years ago. In November 2023, AZ Big Media reported that Silver Sky Development had sold Aquarius for $17 million. That was a 9,635-square-foot estate designed by CP Drewett and built by Arcadia Custom Builders. A month later the outlet covered Silver Sky's Nova, presented at nearly $18.5 million with 11,965 square feet, designed by Stratton Architects and to be built by Arcadia Custom Builders. The team Modern Luxury lists for Hunt Developers in Arizona includes Stratton Architects, Arcadia Custom Builders and Berghoff Design Group.
The same architects and builders show up across several years of projects. So a buyer can compare a 2026 spec against a house the same firms finished only a few years earlier, with similar design and construction. When one of those earlier houses comes up for resale, it gives the buyer a real comparison for any new build in the same price range.
What the Town-Wide Numbers Add
Scottsdale REALTORS' Paradise Valley reports combine single-family homes with condos and townhomes. They describe the town as a whole, not the estate tier, but the change between spring and fall 2026 still helps. In April 2026 the town had 9.38 months of inventory, a 54-day median time on market as measured by RPR, a $2,954,000 median sold price and a 95.2 percent sold-to-list ratio. In September 2026, across 24 sales, inventory had fallen to 6.48 months, median days in RPR to 43, and the median sold price had risen to $3,287,500. The sold-to-list ratio eased slightly to 94.5 percent.
Read together, these figures show a market that tightened between April and September without getting more expensive per foot. Supply fell and homes sold faster. Price per square foot stayed at $775 to $776, so the higher September median came from which homes sold, not from higher prices for comparable space. Buyers were still closing about 5.5 percent below list price in September. That is the same pattern the spec sales show. A well-placed house sells quickly, and the rest are open to negotiation.
For a buyer looking above $10 million, the practical point is to find out where a house is in its builder's cycle before setting an offer. Is it still a plan with a target price, is construction wrapping up, or is it finished and has it been on the market for a while? Our guide to comparing North Scottsdale's luxury communities covers the alternatives many Paradise Valley buyers consider at the same time, and our buyer services page explains how we work with clients through a purchase.
If a new Paradise Valley estate is on your list, Piazza Realty Group can help you place that house in its builder's timeline and weigh it against recent sales of new and nearly new estates in town before you make an offer. Let's Connect.